Gentle reminder: Q fully supports the DeepLeap MetaInfo panel, so if you’re a DeepLeap user, you’ve got access to the search engine, site map, contact page, and home page all at the bottom of your DeepLeap popup window.

I’m fairly disgusted that when John Rocker came into the Atlanta Braves game last night, he got a standing ovation, and fans even held up signs that read “Rocker for President.” Then again, this is a state that still has the Confederate flag incorporated into its state flag, so tolerance can hardly be expected.

A Connecticut couple is suing Publisher’s Clearing House for $21 million, claiming that they received many envelopes in the mail saying that they had actually won the sweepstakes, and even got all dressed up on Super Bowl Sunday to wait for the van and TV cameras to pull up and give them the big fake check. When it didn’t show up, apparently the emotional distress was too much to bear, and a lawsuit was the only answer.

On the other side of the lawsuit coin, I actually agree with the lawsuit filed by Metallica, and the apparently impending lawsuit from Dr. Dre, against Napster for helping distribute their copyrighted works. While people may not agree with the amount charged by major record labels for CDs and tapes, I don’t agree with how much a new BMW Z3 costs, but I don’t have the right to steal one because of that belief. Napster is a content provider, and once they know that a party is providing copyrighted and illegal content, they have to pull it down, just like AOL or EarthLink does.

David Adams has started a discussion on whether or not the Napster lawsuits should include the schools that provide Internet access to students.

Comments

I can see them suing Napster, but should they be able to sue the universities, too? IIRC, they’re also suing Yale, Indiana U, and USC for not blocking Napster. Are they really liable to Metallica for the band’s imagined losses? To me, that part of the lawsuit seems more like a ploy to sue someone who might actually have the cash to pay a judgement.

• Posted by: David Adams on Apr 19, 2000, 3:09 PM

I dunno — while I haven’t firmed up my own opinion on whether or not the universities should be held liable, there’s actually some very logical reasoning behind including them in the suit.

Imagine that you’re EarthLink, and I’m a customer of yours, using you for my dialup access. I put up a webserver, and on that webserver, I provide an MPEG of the entire Star Wars episode one movie. LucasFilms calls you, and says that one of your customers is violating their trademark and providing access to their movie. As far as I understand, if you don’t revoke my access and shut down my webserver, then you are just as liable as I am for the violating of copyright, and are just as exposed to lawsuit as I am.

Now, the universities are all in the same position as EarthLink — they are all internet service providers, for their students. If students then use that internet service to provide access to copyrighted material (material that it is illegal to distribute unless you are the copyright owner), and you know about it, then it is your job to prevent them from doing so.

In this situation, Sprint wouldn’t shut down their clients’ access to the Napster network, they would shut down their clients’ access to the Internet. In the case of the universities, they seem to not want to do that, probably because the networks at schools aren’t set up the same — it’s not like these schools could just disable a login and the students’ computers would be shut out from the network.

Think of it this way: if a Columbia student were providing access to research documents that were confidential property of a Columbia engineering lab, you could be sure that Columbia would cut off that student’s server. They just don’t want to treat the Napster stuff the same way, and they may end up having to pay for that.

• Posted by: Jason Levine on Apr 19, 2000, 3:37 PM

Assume for a moment that yes, Napster should be held responsible. After that, heck, hold the universities responsible. And the states that helped fund the Internet connections for the Universities too, I don’t much care. (Note once you open that door, there’s no logical place to stop, but that’s a seperate point.)

How is Napster-the-company supposed to “remove” all Metallica files from their service? They aren’t serving the files, in fact they don’t serve any files at all. They don’t host the space where people put the MP3s. They only control the search server and while Napster can block all instances of “Metallica”… how are they going to respond when users start calling things “acillateM”, “Mtllca”, and any of thousands of other variations on the name? It’s not like they can reach onto people’s hard drives and delete the offending MP3s. It’s not like they really have control over the service.

Oh, and some of those MP3s are perfectly legit, just illegal to download. Some of them are backed up with Metallica albums. How can they distinguish those, or how will they justify punishing innocent people?

There is a part of me who agrees in some sense, but where this could end up going if it succeeds terrrifies me.

• Posted by: Jeremy Bowers on Apr 19, 2000, 5:08 PM

They can respond by shutting down the search server until they have some reasonable method to prevent the distribution of copyrighted works. And the universities can just shut off inbound access to any computer that they find participating in Napster — and, I’m willing to bet that we’re about to see this start happening.

And as for the MP3s being “legit, just illegal to download” — is Napster anything BUT a sharing service? Unless I misunderstand, Metallica isn’t suing due to the creation of the MP3s, they’re suing because of their distribution. If the people are truly innocent of copyright violation, then the MP3s aren’t indexed in their copy of Napster, they’re whiled away in a backup somewhere.

Again, this all hinges on the fact that feeling like you have some right to something doesn’t translate into having that right. Like it or not, the bands and music companies own rights to that music, and devising a method to get around that on a mass scale isn’t permissible.

• Posted by: Jason Levine on Apr 20, 2000, 9:25 AM

They can respond by shutting down the search server until they have some reasonable method to prevent the distribution of copyrighted works.

If by “reasonable” you mean “reasonably effective”, the only thing that Napster could do would be download each MP3 and examine it individually for copyright compliancy. You absolutely cannot trust the name of the file or the included information (which any half-way decent player allows you to completely modify).

When I used the program and guestimated the amount of time it would take to each MP3 that was online (assuming 1MB=1minute) the answer came out to approx 4.5 thousand years. There is some duplication but you can’t be sure.

I don’t think that “something should be done first” is a legit answer, because I don’t think there is a “something” that can save Napster. Based on your statements and the lack of a reasonable method of protection, I’m perfectly comfortable with claiming that perhaps Napster has no right to exist at all. It would not be the first time I’ve said that about a service.

It really is little more then a systematic way to perform illegal activities, even though it is as neutral as any other tool in theory. My discomfort comes from the courts getting a hold of this and just how far it can be twisted. Shutting down Napster-the-service because of the overwhelmingly illegal activity I’m OK with. Holding Napster-the-company liable for that activity gives me the heebie-jeebies.

From what I’ve seen, Napster was originally intended as a replacement for MP3.com, which distributes perfectly legal MP3s that bands give to the site for that express purpose in the hopes that somebody will see them and either sign them (if they are a label), or at least buy a CD of the song (if they are a normal person). The ability to share your MP3s with others was originally a secondary feature. They didn’t set out from day one to violate every acoustical copyright on the planet.

Of course, the sequel is already on the horizon… Gnutella and friends. Not only is there no way to make sure the content is legal, there’s no way to filter the service in the long-term either. After a few more iterations the only thing that will stop somebody from using Gnutella in a big way is bandwidth caps, and that’s not exactly a targetted solution. By the time the developers get done encrypting the stream, compressing the stream, bouncing around ports and switching off protocols on a whim, there will be no fingerprint that you can look for to block Gnutella. (Napster’s already really hard and all Napster can do is switch ports at will.)

And the universities can just shut off inbound access to any computer that they find participating in Napster — and, I’m willing to bet that we’re about to see this start happening.

Some have done it, albiet nobody has been able to do it 100%, they’ve just blocked the less sophisticated users and those without sophisticated friends.

My university’s network director, much to my shock and the shock of others, has publically committed to not trying shut down Napster… “just don’t download illegal MP3s”. I suspect that if these lawsuits go through, his tune may change.

Again, this all hinges on the fact that feeling like you have some right to something doesn’t translate into having that right.

Heh heh, just try explaining that on Slashdot. I’ve never been moderated down so fast in my life.

• Posted by: Jeremy Bowers on Apr 20, 2000, 12:30 PM
Please note that comments automatically close after 60 days; the comment spammers love to use the older, rarely-viewed pages to work their magic. If comments are closed and you want to let me know something, feel free to use the contact page!

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

vip888

toto

cancertoto

vikingtoto

toto 4d

toto 4d

slot88

vikingtoto

p>bengkulutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://www.xde.com.ph/

https://imperialvets.com/imperial-animal-hospital/contact-us/

densustoto

dewaking

slot

slot

slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs slot

cancer toto

slot

bengkulutoto

slot

toto slot

situs slot

coloktoto login

bengkulutoto

slot

babeltoto

cancertoto

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

slot88

スマスロ

malukutoto

hukumtoto

vikingtoto

viking toto

malukutoto

top1toto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

dewaking

dewaking

situs toto

cancer toto

cancertoto

https://cashwave.live/payment-partner/

vikingtoto

https://www.mundwiler-juwelen.ch/kontakt/

piktoto

heroslot88

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

cancertoto

wiltoto

slot gacor

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

https://www.joyd.my/brand/moda/

bengkulutoto

mamatogel

vespa36

vespa36

coktogel

batmantoto login

coktogel

batmantoto

hukum toto

vikingtoto

viking toto

cancertoto

top1toto

cancertoto

batmantoto.de

cancertoto

kudahoki

batmantoto login

tasiktoto

paitocambodia.name

paitochina.blog

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

depo 5k

viking toto

SITUS SLOT ONLINE

piktoto

toto slot

kartutoto

batman toto

wisdomtoto

toto online

slot toto

situs toto

8kbetplay

slot 5k

8kbetplay

situs slot88

slot 4d

toto togel

situs toto

bandar togel

https://prediksibatmantogel4d.com/

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto

top1toto

top1toto

bydplay

piktoto

bydplay

citibet88

citibet88

cancertoto

top1toto

situs toto cas89

japanlotto.store

kakaktogel

bengkulutoto

piktoto

toto

cancer toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

piktoto

babeltoto

Rtp Slot Gacor

piktoto

Sbobet

Slot Qris

piktoto

Slot Gacor

Toto

hokijp68

bengkulutoto

cancer toto

piktoto

bengkulutoto

rebahin

Savefrom

slot88

slot jackpot

toto

toto

coloktoto.nl

toto

batmantoto login

https://kidneystonemelbourne.com.au/kidney-stones/

vikingtoto

toto

altartoto

toto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

pokemontoto

piktoto

vespa36

vespa36

cancertoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

piktoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

situs togel

togel online

cancer toto

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

slot toto

toto 4d

cancer toto

top1toto

link toto

toto wuhan

situs toto

toto macau

toto slot gacor

daftar toto

batmantoto

coloktoto login

coloktoto login

toto

malukutoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

jitu26 resmi

piktoto

toto

tasiktoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

pokemontoto

rexonatoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

coloktoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto login

toto

vespa36

pokemontoto

situs toto

coktogel login

slot gacor

slot toto

malukutoto

usahatoto

piktoto

situs toto

usahatoto

laetoto login

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

piktoto

malukutoto

top1toto

unsurtoto

malukutoto

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

toto

vespa36

vespa36 resmi

vespa36

vespa36

piktoto

link gacor

cancertoto

piktoto

link gacor

pokemontoto

rajalangit77 official

rajalangit77 togel

https://www.terangtampil.xyz/

malukutoto

top1toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

vespa36

vespa36

viking toto

sesetoto

batmantoto login

bengkulutoto

vespa36

top1toto

vespa36

labirintoto

gelasjitu

balontoto

toto slot

pokemontoto

malukutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://wiltoto.cz/wap/

https://wiltoto.tw/user/

https://wiltoto.pw/register/

coktogel

coktogel

paito taiwan

coktogel

vespa36

malukutoto

vespa36

pokemontoto

cas89 login

indototo

raja88

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

coktogel

hukumtoto

cancertoto

wisdomtoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs toto

cancertoto

toto slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs gacor

slot gacor

situs slot

jitu26

jitu26

jitu26

situs toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

cancertoto

jitu26

pokemontoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

cancertoto

slot gacor

situs toto

toto macau

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

toto

bengkulutoto

tartoto

tartoto

tartoto

jitu26

jitu26

4DHOKI

kientoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

kicautoto

situs toto

dewaking

babeltoto

rajaking

pangkutoto

pokemontoto

jitu26

kicautoto

slot gacor

jitu26

top1toto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

best usa casinos online

majumapan99

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

situs 5k

depo 5k

gacor

medantoto

medantoto

pokemontoto

medantoto

vikingtoto

tasiktoto

slot jp

vespa36

vespa36

depo 5k

situs toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

rajalangit77

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

https://bestroofings.ca/about/

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

rajaking

situs toto

situs toto

cancertoto

kudahoki

bulantogel

bulantogel

cancertoto

kudahoki

pokemontoto

kudahoki

rajaking

cancertoto

raja king

kari4d

bengkulutoto

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

pokemontoto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

KUDAHOKI

bengkulutoto

slot gacor

bengkulutoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

paito hk

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

coktogel

tasiktoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

slot

depo 5k

pokemontoto

situs toto

phoenixreslabs.com

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kari4d

pangkutoto

vikingtoto

flokitoto

pokemontoto

gelasjitu

gelasjitu login

gelasjitu daftar

gelasjitu.org

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

altartoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

wak89

babeltoto

flokitoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tarungtoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

KASKUSTOTO

KASKUSTOTO

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

COKTOGEL

flokitoto

flokitoto

vikingtoto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

bengkulutoto

slot qris

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

toto hoki

toto jp

kari4d

pascol4d

kari4d

toto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

ngawitoto

situs toto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bandar togel

angkringan138

slot gacor

pascol4d

pascol4d

kari4d

kari4d

kicautoto

flokitoto

situs slot

slot gacor mahjong

https://linkneon88.com/

toto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

bengkulutoto

hoki

slot

toto

hoki

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

lgomax99

lgomax99

lgowin99

lgowin99

mpo500

hukumtoto

kicautoto

hukumtoto

hukumtoto

situs toto

situs toto

flokitoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

https://supercok.com/

JEMARI4D

JEMARi4D

JEMARI4D

pas4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

laetoto

laetoto

sekutu4d

flokitoto

vespa36

vespa36

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kakek111

flokitoto

flokitoto

ternatetoto

flokitoto

mega888

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

pascol4d

kari4d

pascol4d

situs toto

wisdomtoto

situs toto

toto macau

situs toto

pascol4d

pascol4d

toto

laetoto

jakartaslot88

jakartaslot88

desabet

tasiktoto

situs toto

desabet

situs toto

top1toto

duniatoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

bulantogel

bulantogel

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

desabet

desabet

tegaltoto

FILM PORNO