Thank you, o you of the three llamas.

The unfathomable occurred — I got more sleep while on call than I usually get when I’m home. Now I don’t know what to do with my day…

After yesterday’s pointer to the Web Standards Project’s open letter to Netscape comes today’s Suck piece. The former asks Netscape to withdraw the 4.X browser from the market; the latter declares the upcoming Mozilla to already be irrelevant and a waste of everyone’s time. My favorite line: “At the very least, the Mozilla Project has given the world a pretty good picture of what caffeine poisoning looks like.”

I forgot that Dennis Miller makes his debut on Monday Night Football tonight; I’ve got to make it home to watch. Unfortunately, tonight is the overwhelmingly boring Hall of Fame game; fortunately, it should provide a few opportunities for Miller to show his humor.

Lance weighs in with a pretty well-though-out and well-written piece about the whole Napster mess. I’m in his boat — I don’t use Napster because I feel that, just as I want other people to honor my copyrights, I will honor others’ copyrights.

Dave Winer keeps saying that he pays for the music he gets on Napster (here and here are the two examples I found, although here he estimates he’s said it 80 times). I wonder how he’s doing that. Oh, I think I get it, after reading today’s SN — all the music he grabs on Napster is music he’s bought at some point, on some media.

OK, in the wake of the Stinky Meat Project comes some British guy who decided to try to contract athlete’s foot (dubbed “StinkyFeet”). He wrapped his feet in bags for sixteen days, jogged, went to the beach, and ended up with feet for which even a 90-year-old diabetic wouldn’t trade. Gross.

In a pretty big breakthrough, NIH researchers have found the specific bit of the Ebola virus that causes massive hemorrhage. This could lead to either a vaccine or blocking antibodies, both of which would be welcome in Africa (the virus’s hunting ground) and worldwide.

There’s not much sadder than a postmortem before a company is dead. From the sounds of things, though, perhaps the company should be.

Comments

I think it’s great that some people only use Napster to download music they have already purchased.

It seems to be fair use to rip your own CDs and create MP3s of them, so downloading MP3s of songs you have on CD isn’t THAT much of a stretch.

However, I wonder if that fair use can be extended to music purchased on lower-quality media, casette and vinyl, for example. Perhaps if the bitrate is low enough? Perhaps it IS fair use already, I don’t know.

But, how does one that justifies Napster usage based on having paid for the music being downloaded justify blindly sharing that music with everyone else in the world without being able to guarantee that the people on the end of the pipe have also paid for the music? Does one’s ethics only work in one direction?

Jim

• Posted by: Jim Roepcke on Jul 31, 2000, 3:43 PM

What if you never add any songs to the folder that’s accessible through Napster? All the songs would be songs that were already available. Also, since I went through my bandwidth-ectomy, I don’t want to share my pitiful pipe with downloaders, that’s just my own selfishness, so I don’t run Napster when I’m not using it. And finally, when they get a pay system in place, as long as it doesn’t have copy protection, I’m going to be the first in line to sign up, assuming it happens this century.

• Posted by: Dave Winer on Jul 31, 2000, 4:35 PM

What if you never add any songs to the folder that’s accessible through Napster? All the songs would be songs that were already available.

Presumably yes, those songs would already be available elsewhere.

But wouldn’t you still be unable to tell whether or not people who you shared the file with also had purchased the songs being transferred?

It’s a paradox. If noone shares music, there isn’t any music on Napster.

But if one does share music, they have to share it with everyone*, not just people they know share the same beliefs and them, and therefore know that only people who have bought those songs will download them.

* please correct me if I’m wrong here, I’m only assuming!

Which means, I guess, that Napster cannot survive, as is, in a world where people would stop sharing music because they couldn’t ensure that only “authorized” people could access them.

So, if someone that believes only paid-for music should be downloaded on Napster wants music available via Napster, they either have to accept the generosity of others who may in fact not be paying for music themselves, and not reciprocate the favour, or they have to suspend their beliefs in good faith of others.

Or, they have to accept that others don’t follow their standards, that people do pirate music, and feel good about themselves for sticking to their own standards.

Quite the ethical challenge, IMHO. :-)

And finally, when they get a pay system in place, as long as it doesn’t have copy protection, I’m going to be the first in line to sign up, assuming it happens this century.

Me too. I think it would be great. I imagined a system where the users of Napster could get compensated (by proxy of the artists themselves, via Napster) for sharing their hard drive space and bandwidth with others.

I mentioned it briefly in this message, and expanded on the idea at the end of this message.

Jim

PS: My original message linked to the wrong message for the “expanded idea”; that has been corrected.

• Posted by: Jim Roepcke on Jul 31, 2000, 5:50 PM

Of course, services that work like Napster works now (services which do not compensate artists in any way) will always exist, I don’t think there’s any way to stop that.

I support an alternative Napster (it doesn’t have to be from Napster, Inc. of course) service that gives me the option to compensate the artists, and even the source of of the music (the p on the other side of the p2p equation), whether directly or byproxy of the service.

• Posted by: Jim Roepcke on Jul 31, 2000, 6:04 PM

I don’t think it’s an ethical challenge, I’m responsible for myself and only myself. I hope other people are honorable. I also believe strongly that the music industry should have seen this coming and been prepared for it. I saw it coming years ago, that’s why I wrote about music so much, and linked it to my website, as much as I dared to. I agree with Clay Shirky, it’s like driving 70 MPH. I must admit that I do that. So does everyone else on 280, the road I take to SF from my house. And it’s easy to be honorable. I have the disposable income to afford the habit, and most of the music I get is just old stuff I had forgotten about. Today I’m listening to a CD that I used to listen to when I wrote ThinkTank for the Apple II. I forgot how good it was, my memory of the music was so tired. Nahhh, when it actually comes on the speakers I get goosebumps. That’s the point I think a lot of people don’t get, there’s an emotional personal involvement in music that nothing else has. I don’t feel passionately about driving 70 MPH, I just do it because I want to get there sooner and there’s safety in numbers. And when I see a cop car I hit the brakes. (But not if he’s behind me.)

• Posted by: Dave Winer on Jul 31, 2000, 9:36 PM

I guess my problem is that I could apply pretty similar logic to having bought Frontier 1.0 way back when (which we at SI did), and now feeling like I’m entitled to all the new copies off of a file-sharing system without paying for them.

I’m making the assumption that the CD you’re listening to today is probably one you never bought on CD, but instead on an inferior medium (vinyl, 8-track, cassette); upgrading to the CD-quality music isn’t something that your original “license” to the music entitled you to do. Likewise, my original Frontier 1.0 license didn’t tell me I got v6.2.1 free.

Why should the music industry have to give into music sharing just because they could have predicted that it would exist? That’s like saying that the software industry should just give away its products because it was logical to anticipate people sharing their software (something that’s much, much more predictible than music sharing, in my opinion, since programs are inherently digital bits that don’t have to be “ripped” or encoded in order to swap them).

/jason

• Posted by: Jason Levine on Aug 1, 2000, 7:20 AM

The whole thing is so blurry. They never said we couldn’t make tapes of music we had purchased. And they never said if a new distribution medium came out I’d have to buy the same music again. Even so, I did. I’ve bought the same music over and over. Now I want to do it again.

• Posted by: Dave Winer on Aug 2, 2000, 1:30 PM

This is a cop-out. If you think that everything that we buy should come with big licenses, then I would hate to live in that world; every book, toy, candle, mug, hat, poster, and on and on would have to come with legal language. Ugh. (It’s notions like this that force coupon vendors to print “this has no cash value” on their coupons, lest someone demand the $5.00 cash that the would have saved with the rectangle of paper snipped out from their 25-cent newspaper.)

I’m reasonably certain that you have never walked into a bookstore and demanded, for free, the softcover version of a book that you own in hardcover; I also doubt that a bookseller ever explicitly explained that this is how it works. Instead, you used logic to figure that one out. I assume that you also have recognized that owning Jaws on videotape doesn’t entitle you to the DVD version of the movie without forking over the money for it, or that buying a print poster of the Mona Lisa doesn’t mean you can walk into the Louvre and take the real thing off the wall.

Likewise, just because I want Userland to come out with a licensing mechanism for Frontier that lets me pay by the user doesn’t mean that the lack of said mechanism allows me to just download it for free off of a theft network and then proclaim loudly that if that mechanism were to exist, then I would be glad to pay. Instead, I’ve got to pay the only way that the current arrangement lets me, or forgo using the product.

People seem to think that new laws are needed to deal with the complexities of the Internet and copyright. That’s a load of crap, for most things; the same laws cover the same ideas, that theft is bad, that you usually only own one license to one form of a creative work, and that if you disagree with these rules, then you always have the option of not listening to the friggin’ music, not using the software, not buying the book, or whatever.

• Posted by: Jason Levine on Aug 2, 2000, 5:22 PM
Please note that comments automatically close after 60 days; the comment spammers love to use the older, rarely-viewed pages to work their magic. If comments are closed and you want to let me know something, feel free to use the contact page!

slot88

vikingtoto

p>bengkulutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://www.xde.com.ph/

https://imperialvets.com/imperial-animal-hospital/contact-us/

densustoto

dewaking

slot

slot

slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs slot

slot

bengkulutoto

slot

toto slot

toto slot

situs slot

coloktoto login

bengkulutoto

slot

babeltoto

cancertoto

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

slot88

スマスロ

malukutoto

hukumtoto

vikingtoto

viking toto

malukutoto

top1toto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

batmantoto

slot gacor

situs toto

cancer toto

cancertoto

https://cashwave.live/payment-partner/

vikingtoto

https://www.mundwiler-juwelen.ch/kontakt/

piktoto

heroslot88

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

cancertoto

wiltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

https://www.joyd.my/brand/moda/

bengkulutoto

mamatogel

vespa36

vespa36

coktogel

batmantoto login

coktogel

batmantoto

hukum toto

vikingtoto

viking toto

cancertoto

top1toto

cancertoto

batmantoto.de

cancertoto

kudahoki

batmantoto login

tasiktoto

paitocambodia.name

paitochina.blog

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

depo 5k

viking toto

SITUS SLOT ONLINE

piktoto

toto slot

kartutoto

batman toto

wisdomtoto

toto online

slot toto

situs toto

8kbetplay

slot 5k

8kbetplay

situs slot88

slot 4d

toto togel

situs toto

bandar togel

https://prediksibatmantogel4d.com/

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto

top1toto

top1toto

bydplay

bydplay

citibet88

citibet88

cancertoto

top1toto

situs toto cas89

japanlotto.store

kakaktogel

bengkulutoto

piktoto

toto

cancer toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

piktoto

babeltoto

Rtp Slot Gacor

piktoto

Sbobet

Slot Qris

piktoto

Slot Gacor

Toto

hokijp68

bengkulutoto

cancer toto

piktoto

bengkulutoto

rebahin

Savefrom

slot88

slot jackpot

toto

toto

coloktoto.nl

toto

batmantoto login

https://kidneystonemelbourne.com.au/kidney-stones/

vikingtoto

toto

altartoto

toto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

pokemontoto

piktoto

vespa36

vespa36

cancertoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

piktoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

situs togel

togel online

cancer toto

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

slot toto

toto 4d

cancer toto

top1toto

link toto

toto wuhan

situs toto

toto macau

toto slot gacor

daftar toto

batmantoto

coloktoto login

coloktoto login

toto

malukutoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

jitu26 resmi

piktoto

toto

tasiktoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

pokemontoto

rexonatoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

coloktoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto login

toto

vespa36

pokemontoto

situs toto

coktogel login

slot gacor

slot toto

malukutoto

usahatoto

piktoto

situs toto

usahatoto

laetoto login

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

piktoto

malukutoto

top1toto

unsurtoto

malukutoto

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

toto

vespa36

vespa36 resmi

vespa36

vespa36

piktoto

link gacor

cancertoto

piktoto

link gacor

pokemontoto

rajalangit77 official

rajalangit77 togel

https://www.terangtampil.xyz/

malukutoto

top1toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

vespa36

vespa36

viking toto

sesetoto

batmantoto login

bengkulutoto

vespa36

top1toto

vespa36

labirintoto

gelasjitu

balontoto

toto slot

pokemontoto

malukutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://wiltoto.cz/wap/

https://wiltoto.tw/user/

https://wiltoto.pw/register/

coktogel

coktogel

paito taiwan

coktogel

vespa36

malukutoto

vespa36

pokemontoto

cas89 login

indototo

raja88

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

coktogel

hukumtoto

cancertoto

wisdomtoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs toto

cancertoto

toto slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs gacor

slot gacor

situs slot

jitu26

jitu26

jitu26

jitu26

situs toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

cancertoto

jitu26

pokemontoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

cancertoto

slot gacor

situs toto

toto macau

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

toto

bengkulutoto

tartoto

tartoto

tartoto

jitu26

jitu26

4DHOKI

kientoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

kicautoto

situs toto

dewaking

babeltoto

rajaking

pangkutoto

pokemontoto

jitu26

kicautoto

slot gacor

jitu26

top1toto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

best usa casinos online

majumapan99

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

situs 5k

depo 5k

gacor

medantoto

medantoto

pokemontoto

medantoto

vikingtoto

tasiktoto

slot jp

vespa36

vespa36

depo 5k

situs toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

rajalangit77

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

https://bestroofings.ca/about/

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

rajaking

situs toto

situs toto

cancertoto

kudahoki

bulantogel

bulantogel

cancertoto

kudahoki

pokemontoto

kudahoki

rajaking

cancertoto

raja king

kari4d

bengkulutoto

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

pokemontoto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

KUDAHOKI

bengkulutoto

slot gacor

bengkulutoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

paito hk

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

coktogel

tasiktoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

slot

depo 5k

pokemontoto

situs toto

phoenixreslabs.com

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kari4d

pangkutoto

vikingtoto

flokitoto

pokemontoto

gelasjitu

gelasjitu login

gelasjitu daftar

gelasjitu.org

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

altartoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

wak89

babeltoto

flokitoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tarungtoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

KASKUSTOTO

KASKUSTOTO

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

COKTOGEL

flokitoto

flokitoto

vikingtoto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

bengkulutoto

slot qris

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

toto hoki

toto jp

kari4d

pascol4d

kari4d

toto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

ngawitoto

situs toto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bandar togel

angkringan138

slot gacor

pascol4d

pascol4d

kari4d

kari4d

kicautoto

flokitoto

situs slot

slot gacor mahjong

https://linkneon88.com/

toto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

bengkulutoto

hoki

slot

toto

hoki

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

lgomax99

lgomax99

lgowin99

lgowin99

mpo500

hukumtoto

kicautoto

hukumtoto

hukumtoto

situs toto

situs toto

flokitoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

https://supercok.com/

JEMARI4D

JEMARi4D

JEMARI4D

pas4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

laetoto

laetoto

sekutu4d

flokitoto

vespa36

vespa36

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kakek111

flokitoto

flokitoto

ternatetoto

flokitoto

mega888

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

pascol4d

kari4d

pascol4d

situs toto

wisdomtoto

situs toto

toto macau

situs toto

pascol4d

pascol4d

toto

laetoto

jakartaslot88

jakartaslot88

desabet

tasiktoto

situs toto

desabet

situs toto

top1toto

duniatoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

bulantogel

bulantogel

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

desabet

desabet

tegaltoto

FILM PORNO