Over in the little kingdom of Wikipedia, a war is brewing that’s just pissing me off. There’s a specific user who seems to have an enormous, overarching hatred of Ajax (the web development technology encompassing asynchronous JavaScript, the Document Object Model, and DHTML), and in the furtherance of his hatred, appears to be absolutely hellbent on pissing all over everything related to it on Wikipedia. (He even chose his name to be a pun on the name of a well-known user who is proficient in Ajax technologies.) The user has been involved in huge revert wars on the Ajax article itself, and recently has also started monomaniacally adding a critical section to the page of Jesse James Garrett (the author of the article coining the Ajax name). Whenever anyone challenges his edits, the user throws a tantrum, makes wild accusations, and reverts the page to the last version he had defaced. (For example, when I edited his section to remove a falsely-attributed quote, remove a bit of bile, and delete a pointedly biased link to the defacer’s own website, he just called my edits “vandalism” and reverted them.) As of today, he’s managed to get an administrator to lock both pages from further edits, freezing them in a state that includes his vomitus.

To me, this highlights my biggest frustration with Wikipedia — that in an effort to allow communal access and editing of the encyclopedia, it makes the entire product susceptible to childish wailing and harrassment, and only pages that become high-profile develop enough community defense and generate enough community discussion to keep the miscreants at bay. When the pages aren’t high enough profile, such as the the case with the pages on Ajax and Jesse James Garrett, users with grudges might be able to pull the wool over the eyes of a gullible administrator and get him or her to intervene, lock the pages, and prevent anyone else from having an opinion. It’s all just screwed up beyond belief.

What can you do? I’m not all that sure. For now, you can go over to the relevant pages — the discussion page on the Jesse James Garrett article, the discussion page on the Ajax article, and the talk page for the admin user who locked the pages — and engage in reasoned discourse on why this whole mess is stupid. Perhaps logic and discussion might help (although I doubt it, since I’ve been trying for a week or two without much success). If that doesn’t work, perhaps others can try to bring this in front of the arbitration committee over at Wikipedia, since I’m rapidly losing both the energy and the interest in saving Wikipedia from itself. Maybe someone else has a better answer, though; I certainly don’t.

Update: a nice user dropped me an email that comments were totally broken; it’s fixed now.

Comments

This is a great example of why we are trying a different approach with Consumerpedia.org

All feedback and suggestions from you or your readers on how to make the Consumerpedia system better would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

A quick short-hand version of the core difference (more on our Blog and About page…)

“Eternal vigilance is the price of a wiki” - meaning that with a system like Wikipedia, since anyone can edit anything at any time, you need people who are willing and able to watch and correct “bad” edits at any time. The stabilizing factor with Wikipedia is the ever vigilant users.

“Cumulative vigilance is the benefit of Consumerpedia” - meaning that with a system like Consumerpedia, as users rate the helpfulness of comments and suggestions (and thus indirectly also rate the users who made those comments and suggestions - and also indirectly rate themselves as to how well their ratings correlate with those provided by others), the collective wisdom of what and who is good and bad (helpful and not helpful) grows over time. The stabilizing factor of Consumerpedia is the nature of the Consumerpedia system itself.

• Posted by: Consumerpedia on Aug 16, 2005, 6:15 AM

You find it “beyond belief” that a high-profile encyclopedia that can be modified by any idiot with a computer might get screwed up? Well, I admit that Wikipedia is far more robust than I would have thought possible, as this “healing experiment” demonstrates:

http://alex.halavais.net/news/index.php?p=794

And I think the quality of the articles that I’ve looked at is quite good. But I’ve noticed a trend for people to link to Wikipedia articles as a catch-all reference, and I think this might be unwise: when your reader follows your link, he might find something that has been modified to be far different from the article you thought you were sending him to. So while Wikipedia might be fascinating and the efforts of its contributors admirable, it would seem to be fundamentally too unstable to be used as an actual online encyclopedia.

• Posted by: Lee Phillips on Aug 16, 2005, 10:39 AM

I’ve become frustrated with Wikipedia for just such reasons — and I agree with Lee Phillips’ comment above that it’s a good resource, but shouldn’t be considered an actual encyclopedia. I think certain users look at certain articles as their exclusive fiefs, and brook no updates unless they wrote them themselves. An example: I was doing some research on the Boeing 737 aircraft series a little while back, and in the course of doing so ran across a Boeing.com page with information that made it clear that some of the Wikipedia article on the 737 was outdated. I made some fixes and linked to the reference page, but the page was quickly reverted to its older version, with no reason given. I tried to make the fix again, with the same result. And again a third time.

(I decided that I’m not gonna fight the guy, whoever he is, because that’s really not how I care to spend my time.)

• Posted by: Vidiot on Aug 16, 2005, 12:35 PM

Of course! It’s allways the wrong version.

• Posted by: Matt Hampel on Aug 16, 2005, 5:13 PM

Shit does indeed happen, and from all accounts (though I’m not versed in AJAX enough to know) this situation sucks. But give it a bit of time. I’d be willing to take bets that the mistakes Q pointed out will be fixed within a month. (Yes, this is only one instance, a high-profile example, and more tends to get done about high-profile examples.

Consumerpedia: I’m not sure relying on auto-summed, explicit, numerical repuations systems will work. Two thirds of our brains are devtoed to natural social interaction; there’s some incredibly powerful stuff there. Explicit reputation systems tend to break the inbuilt implicit reputation systems (scaling that implicit system can be a bitch, of course, but wikipedia’s done well so far).

I think, really that more people of expertise need to get involved in things they know about and start treating wikipedia as a serious resource to be protected. Some work is involved, yes, but not very much if it’s distributed well. The balance of wikipedia power has been shifting away from the crackpots for awhile now.

• Posted by: Ben Yates on Aug 17, 2005, 2:21 AM
Please note that comments automatically close after 60 days; the comment spammers love to use the older, rarely-viewed pages to work their magic. If comments are closed and you want to let me know something, feel free to use the contact page!

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

vip888

toto

cancertoto

vikingtoto

toto 4d

toto 4d

slot88

vikingtoto

p>bengkulutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://www.xde.com.ph/

https://imperialvets.com/imperial-animal-hospital/contact-us/

densustoto

dewaking

slot

slot

slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs slot

cancer toto

slot

bengkulutoto

slot

toto slot

situs slot

coloktoto login

bengkulutoto

slot

babeltoto

cancertoto

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

slot88

スマスロ

malukutoto

hukumtoto

vikingtoto

viking toto

malukutoto

top1toto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

dewaking

dewaking

situs toto

cancer toto

cancertoto

https://cashwave.live/payment-partner/

vikingtoto

https://www.mundwiler-juwelen.ch/kontakt/

piktoto

heroslot88

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

cancertoto

wiltoto

slot gacor

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

https://www.joyd.my/brand/moda/

bengkulutoto

mamatogel

vespa36

vespa36

coktogel

batmantoto login

coktogel

batmantoto

hukum toto

vikingtoto

viking toto

cancertoto

top1toto

cancertoto

batmantoto.de

cancertoto

kudahoki

batmantoto login

tasiktoto

paitocambodia.name

paitochina.blog

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

depo 5k

viking toto

SITUS SLOT ONLINE

piktoto

toto slot

kartutoto

batman toto

wisdomtoto

toto online

slot toto

situs toto

8kbetplay

slot 5k

8kbetplay

situs slot88

slot 4d

toto togel

situs toto

bandar togel

https://prediksibatmantogel4d.com/

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto

top1toto

top1toto

bydplay

piktoto

bydplay

citibet88

citibet88

cancertoto

top1toto

situs toto cas89

japanlotto.store

kakaktogel

bengkulutoto

piktoto

toto

cancer toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

piktoto

babeltoto

Rtp Slot Gacor

piktoto

Sbobet

Slot Qris

piktoto

Slot Gacor

Toto

hokijp68

bengkulutoto

cancer toto

piktoto

bengkulutoto

rebahin

Savefrom

slot88

slot jackpot

toto

toto

coloktoto.nl

toto

batmantoto login

https://kidneystonemelbourne.com.au/kidney-stones/

vikingtoto

toto

altartoto

toto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

pokemontoto

piktoto

vespa36

vespa36

cancertoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

piktoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

situs togel

togel online

cancer toto

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

slot toto

toto 4d

cancer toto

top1toto

link toto

toto wuhan

situs toto

toto macau

toto slot gacor

daftar toto

batmantoto

coloktoto login

coloktoto login

toto

malukutoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

jitu26 resmi

piktoto

toto

tasiktoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

pokemontoto

rexonatoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

batmantoto

batmantoto

coloktoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

batmantoto login

toto

vespa36

pokemontoto

situs toto

coktogel login

slot gacor

slot toto

malukutoto

usahatoto

piktoto

situs toto

usahatoto

laetoto login

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

piktoto

malukutoto

top1toto

unsurtoto

malukutoto

unsurtoto

unsurtoto

toto

vespa36

vespa36 resmi

vespa36

vespa36

piktoto

link gacor

cancertoto

piktoto

link gacor

pokemontoto

rajalangit77 official

rajalangit77 togel

https://www.terangtampil.xyz/

malukutoto

top1toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

piktoto

jitu26

jitu26

vespa36

vespa36

viking toto

sesetoto

batmantoto login

bengkulutoto

vespa36

top1toto

vespa36

labirintoto

gelasjitu

balontoto

toto slot

pokemontoto

malukutoto

สล็อตเว็บตรง

https://wiltoto.cz/wap/

https://wiltoto.tw/user/

https://wiltoto.pw/register/

coktogel

coktogel

paito taiwan

coktogel

vespa36

malukutoto

vespa36

pokemontoto

cas89 login

indototo

raja88

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

coktogel

hukumtoto

cancertoto

wisdomtoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs toto

cancertoto

toto slot

cancertoto

cancertoto

situs gacor

slot gacor

situs slot

jitu26

jitu26

jitu26

situs toto

babeltoto

babeltoto

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26

cancertoto

jitu26

pokemontoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

cancertoto

slot gacor

situs toto

toto macau

vespa36

vespa36

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

toto

bengkulutoto

tartoto

tartoto

tartoto

jitu26

jitu26

4DHOKI

kientoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

kicautoto

situs toto

dewaking

babeltoto

rajaking

pangkutoto

pokemontoto

jitu26

kicautoto

slot gacor

jitu26

top1toto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

best usa casinos online

majumapan99

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

situs 5k

depo 5k

gacor

medantoto

medantoto

pokemontoto

medantoto

vikingtoto

tasiktoto

slot jp

vespa36

vespa36

depo 5k

situs toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

rajalangit77

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

https://bestroofings.ca/about/

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

rajaking

situs toto

situs toto

cancertoto

kudahoki

bulantogel

bulantogel

cancertoto

kudahoki

pokemontoto

kudahoki

rajaking

cancertoto

raja king

kari4d

bengkulutoto

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

kaostogel

pokemontoto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

KUDAHOKI

bengkulutoto

slot gacor

bengkulutoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

paito hk

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

coktogel

tasiktoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

top1toto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

rajaking

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

toto

slot

depo 5k

pokemontoto

situs toto

phoenixreslabs.com

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kari4d

pangkutoto

vikingtoto

flokitoto

pokemontoto

gelasjitu

gelasjitu login

gelasjitu daftar

gelasjitu.org

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

altartoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

slot

flokitoto

wak89

babeltoto

flokitoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

tarungtoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

KASKUSTOTO

KASKUSTOTO

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

COKTOGEL

flokitoto

flokitoto

vikingtoto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

bengkulutoto

slot qris

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

toto hoki

toto jp

kari4d

pascol4d

kari4d

toto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

ngawitoto

situs toto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

bandar togel

angkringan138

slot gacor

pascol4d

pascol4d

kari4d

kari4d

kicautoto

flokitoto

situs slot

slot gacor mahjong

https://linkneon88.com/

toto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

bengkulutoto

hoki

slot

toto

hoki

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

lgomax99

lgomax99

lgowin99

lgowin99

mpo500

hukumtoto

kicautoto

hukumtoto

hukumtoto

situs toto

situs toto

flokitoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

https://supercok.com/

JEMARI4D

JEMARi4D

JEMARI4D

pas4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

laetoto

laetoto

sekutu4d

flokitoto

vespa36

vespa36

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

kakek111

flokitoto

flokitoto

ternatetoto

flokitoto

mega888

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

pascol4d

kari4d

pascol4d

situs toto

wisdomtoto

situs toto

toto macau

situs toto

pascol4d

pascol4d

toto

laetoto

jakartaslot88

jakartaslot88

desabet

tasiktoto

situs toto

desabet

situs toto

top1toto

duniatoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

bulantogel

bulantogel

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

desabet

desabet

tegaltoto

FILM PORNO