Traditional spam-catching systems work by predicting the likelihood of a piece of email being an unsolicited ad. The task of prediction isn’t easy, though, and as a result, users still have to deal both with unwanted mail that gets through the filters and with legitimate mail that’s caught and filtered away. As a result, there are a few ideas floating around out there about alternate approaches to the unsolicited email problem, approaches that try to achieve lower false-positive and false-negative rates. Two that caught my eye today are IronPort’s Bonded Sender Program and Habeas’ Sender Warranted Email.

The Bonded Sender Program turns the traditional approach around, aiming to guarantee that a specific piece of mail is not spam. It’s able to do this because companies contract with, and pay, IronPort to list their outgoing mail servers in a database of machines guaranteed not to send spam. Then, when your mail server accepts a piece of mail from a machine, it checks to see if that machine is listed in IronPort’s database, and if it is, the mail flows through any spam filters and into your inbox. This seems like a great way for companies that operate legitimate, double-opt-in email lists to make sure that their sales missives reach the intended audience — it appears to be poison-proof (meaning that spammers can’t fake the system into thinking that they’re legitimate), and at least one of the big spam filter providers, SpamAssassin, is on board.

Sender Warranted Email works in another way, and one that I can’t imagine will be able to sustain itself. Senders “warrant” that their email isn’t spam by including a “trademarked, copyrighted” set of headers that they’ve paid for the right to use; it’s these headers that filters look for to decide that the mail is legitimate. Habeas promises to aggressively sue anyone who uses the headers without the right to do so, providing the teeth behind the system. (Wired News wrote about this back in August.) Unfortunately, I envision that almost every piece of unsolicited email will soon include the headers, in an effort to overwhelm Habeas and make the company unable to go after everyone who is circumventing the rules. (You know the signature block that still graces the bottom of mail unsolicited emails, claiming to be acceptable under some obscure Senate rule? Same thing.)

Despite the questionable long-term effectiveness of Habeas’ approach, I applaud both companies for coming up with new ways of attacking the problem. With spam making up an estimated one third of email sent daily, someone’s got to tackle this problem before it takes the entire mode of communication down with it.

Comments

I think people are giving up on automated solutions too easily. I’ve seen a lot of articles recently (your post, the Slate article yesterday) that dismiss automated solutions in the first paragraph, with a single sentence: “it’s hard!” Well, that’s why we have bright computer people.

Paul Graham has created a spam filter that learns the difference between spam and non-spam, using Basyesian statistical techniques: “we now miss less than 5 per 1000 spams, with 0 false positives.” And this is using a naive Bayesian technique, assuming that words appear independently. Allowing probabilities to be chained together — reverse Markov chaining, basically - would yield even better results (although at a speed cost.)

• Posted by: Lukas Bergstrom on Nov 21, 2002, 12:48 PM

Most spam I get is from 3rd cousins sending me “humor” — any bonding to fight that?

(btw: I got this trying to post here:

Your comment had the following errors, which you need to correct below:

Name and email address are required.

…and I’m supposed to trust you? [silly smirk])

• Posted by: victor on Nov 21, 2002, 1:41 PM

I agree with you about the coolness of Bayesian filtering, but that being said, I don’t know if it will be a panacea. In order for it to be truly effective on the individual user level, it requires the users to train it about what is and isn’t spam before they start using it. The whole point of Bayesian filtering is its acknowledgement that everyone’s incoming mail is different; words like cancer and prescription are more likely to be in legitimate email to a doctor than they are to a web programmer. If there were to be a more generic Bayesian filter implemented at the consumer level (i.e., one which the programmers have trained with a corpus of generic spam and generic “good” mail), then it’s not really trained for the users who are using it, and the likelihood of false positives and negatives increases.

(Note that this is just my poor-man’s perspective on it; being a statistical solution, the statistics community has also published critiques (PDFs) of the Bayesian approach that offer far more than I can in the way of analysis.)

All that being said, there’s clearly a lot to be offered by a well-implemented Bayesian filter. Since Paul’s article, there has been a flurry of activity on the programming front; here are the options, available for use today, that I have found in about ten minutes of searching: BogoFilter, spambayes, Bayesian Mail Filter, spamcan, Bayespam, SpamSieve, POPFile, and spamfilter. And the happy news for SpamAssassin users is that the soon-to-be-released version 2.50 adds Bayesian filtering. All this means is that the spamcatching method is going to be tested in the real world, which can only be a good thing.

(And, on preview: yeah, Victor, you can trust me. [smirk of my own])

• Posted by: Jason on Nov 21, 2002, 2:25 PM

Excellent summary of Bayesian mail filtering, thanks. I don’t think asking users to train their own spam filters is too much of a barrier. It would be enough to have a ‘Delete and Mark as Spam’ button. If the program then assumes that anything not marked as spam can be placed in the ‘good’ corpus, training the filter should be quick and painless.

Can you imagine if Microsoft integrated this into Hotmail? It would be a win for them: people would pay for effective spam-blocking. And it would, in the end, be a win for everyone, because the incentive to spam would go down.

• Posted by: Lukas Bergstrom on Nov 21, 2002, 2:38 PM
Please note that comments automatically close after 60 days; the comment spammers love to use the older, rarely-viewed pages to work their magic. If comments are closed and you want to let me know something, feel free to use the contact page!

vikingtoto

https://imperialvets.com/imperial-animal-hospital/contact-us/

densustoto

tasiktoto

slot

slot

slot

slot

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

slot

cancertoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

situs toto

パチスロ

hukum toto

vikingtoto

viking toto

vikingtoto

tasiktoto

malukutoto

top1toto

tasiktoto

batman toto

slot gacor

slot gacor

https://www.cch-rc.com/careers/

situs toto

cancertoto

https://cashwave.live/payment-partner/

slot88

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

viking toto

situs toto

cancertoto

mpo500

bengkulutoto

https://www.joyd.my/brand/moda/

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

piktoto

viking toto

bengkulutoto

mama togel

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

batmantoto login

hukumtoto

cancertoto

top1 toto

cancertoto

bengkulutoto

batmantoto.de

tasiktoto

paitocambodia.name

cancertoto

wisdomtoto

bengkulutoto

hukumtoto link alternatif

vikingtoto

wisdomtoto

kartutoto

toto slot

situs toto

situs depo 5k

8kbetplay

slot88 gacor

toto slot 4d

situs togel

toto 4d

kudahoki

cancertoto

cancertoto

bydplay resmi

bydplay login

citibet88 login

mega99 login

top1toto login

top1toto login

mpo500

piktoto

piktoto

cancertoto

top1toto

cas89

japanlotto.store

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

bengkulutoto

babeltoto

Rtp Slot Gacor

Sbobet

Slot Qris

Slot Gacor

Toto

depo 5k

slot88

slot jackpot

7amnews.in

cancertoto

wiltoto

toto

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

jitu26 resmi

situs toto

jitu26 resmi

vespa36 resmi

wisdomtoto

wisdomtoto

KILAU4D

KILAU4D

piktoto

KILAU4D

altartoto

KILAU4D

KILAU4D

batman toto

batman toto

batman toto

piktoto

cancertoto

piktoto

batman toto

batman toto

situs togel

togel online

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

SITUS SLOT ONLINE

jitu26 login

jitu26 resmi

top1 toto

maluku toto

tasiktoto

cancertoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

pokemontoto

pokemontoto

piktoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

batman toto

batman toto

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

toto slot

rexonatoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

Mix parlay

vespa36

vespa36 resmi

piktoto

toto slot

vespa36

vespa36 login

piktoto

unsur toto

unsur toto

situs toto

piktoto

unsur toto

unsur toto

maluku toto

unsur toto

jitu26 resmi

piktoto

piktoto

slot gacor

jitu26 resmi

top1 toto

vespa36

vespa36

pokemontoto

rajalangit77 toto

mpo 500

projektoto

slot

sesetoto login

piktoto

bengkulutoto

maluku toto

cancer toto

vespa36

top1toto login

maluku toto

vespa36

toto slot

piktoto

enoki77

gelasjitu

balontoto

situs toto

malukutoto login

สล็อตเว็บตรง

pokemontoto

wiltoto.cz/wap/

piktoto

wiltoto.tw/user/

wiltoto.pw/register/

paito taiwan

situs toto

vikingtoto

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

indototo

raja88

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

hukum toto

maluku toto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

cancertoto

toto slot

wisdomtoto

toto

cancertoto

cancertoto

jitu26 resmi

jitu26 resmi

JEMARI4D

JEMARI4D

JEMARI4D

JEMARI4D

depo 5k

jitu26 resmi

vikingtoto

cancer toto

vikingtoto

babeltoto

vespa36

babeltoto

vespa36 resmi

vespa36 resmi

jitu26 resmi

jitu26 resmi

slot gacor

cancer toto

situs toto

toto macau

vespa36

vespa36

jitu26 resmi

jitu26 resmi

jitu26

jitu26

majumapan 99

pokemontoto

situs 5k

depo 5k

slot gacor

vespa36 resmi

top1 toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

kicautoto

vespa36 resmi

medantoto

medantoto

pokemontoto

medantoto

toto 4d

pokemontoto

vikingtoto

dewaking

rajaking

tasiktoto

kicautoto

bengkulutoto

kari4d

hukum toto

depo 5k

depo 5k

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

depo 5k

cancer toto

rajaking

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

rajaking

kari4d

pokemontoto

pascol4d

pucuk4d

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

slot gacor

bulantogel

pokemontoto

bulantogel

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

rajaking

babeltoto

vikingtoto

hukumtoto

hukumtoto

cancer toto

hukumtoto

paito hk

rajaking

toto

pokemontoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

mahjong ways slot mahjong ways slot mahjong mahjong slot

bengkulutoto

cancertoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

vikingtoto

bengkulutoto

dewaking

top1toto

rajaking

toto

slot

depo 5k

pokemontoto

wisdomtoto

gelas jitu

gelas jitu login

gelas jitu daftar

gelasjitu.org

mpo500

pokemontoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

kari4d

vikingtoto

toto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

viking toto

https://ferreclicks.mx/cepillos/

vikingtoto

hukumtoto

vikingtoto

flokitoto

pokemontoto

altartoto

flokitoto

wisdomtoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

mpo500 login

mpo500 login

mpo500 login

flokitoto

flokitoto

wak89

slot

babeltoto

dewaking

flokitoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

KASKUSTOTO

KASKUSTOTO

flokitoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

kari4d

kari4d

vikingtoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

vikingtoto

kari4d

pascol4d

pascol4d

situs toto

situs toto

vespa36

pascol4d

kari4d

situs toto

bengkulutoto

kari4d

kari4d

pascol4d

toto hoki

pascol4d

toto jp

toto

slot qris server thailand

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

pascol4d

pascol4d

pascol4d

kari4d

kari4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

toto hoki

kari4d

kari4d

kari4d

flokitoto

bengkulutoto

tasiktoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

mpo500

mpo 500

angkringan138

flokitoto

pascol4d

neon88

cas89

mpo500

flokitoto

slot gacor

https://linkneon88.com/

slot

toto

kicautoto

wisdomtoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

bengkulutoto

kicautoto

bengkulutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

gacor

bolaslot88

hukum toto

vespa36

vespa36

kicautoto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

situs toto

flokitoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

https://supercok.com/

bengkulutoto

pas4d

flokitoto

flokitoto

laetoto

laetoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

pascol4d

kari4d

pascol4d

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

ternatetoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

pascol4d

pascol4d

pascol4d

tasiktoto

hoki

toto

abcslot gacor

slot 5000

pucuk4d

kari4d

kari4d

jakartaslot88

jakartaslot88

desabet

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

desabet

top1toto

dunia toto

flokitoto

flokitoto

babeltoto

bengkulutoto

toto

medantoto

medantoto

medantoto

bulantogel

bulantogel

flokitoto

batmantoto17.com

toto slot

kimia4d

laetoto

tasiktoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

laetoto

Link situs sipjitu

kakaktogel

prediksijitukakaktogel.com

togel online

kari4d

kari4d

cancertoto

bengkulutoto

bengkulutoto

laetoto

flokitoto

slot demo

slot gacor

slot gacor

slot

slot jackpot

kari4d

kimia4d

bokep bocil

mega888 malaysia

pucuk4d

slot gacor

tasiktoto

inclavecasinos

flokitoto

flokitoto

babeltoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

pucuk4d

situs toto

ทดลองเล่นสล็อต

flokitoto

kimia4d

rakutoto

wajibslot

PAPUATOTO

rajaking

damaibet

malukutoto

mpo500

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

malukutoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

flokitoto

mataramtoto

slot gacor

tasiktoto

rupiahbet

slot gacor

kuda hoki

tasiktoto

manadototo

sayangbet

sayangbet

sayangbet

sayangbet

sayangbet

sayangbet

sayangbet

manadototo

cancer toto

manadototo

PASCOL4D

kimia 4d

slot demo

demo mahjong ways

slot server thailand

LGOGACOR

medantoto

situs toto

wak89

FLOKITOTO

dunia toto

cukongbet

laetoto

hukum toto

slot

babeltoto

tasiktoto

hukum toto

เว็บสล็อต แท้ 100 เปอร์เซ็นต์

dunia toto

laetoto

tasiktoto

malukutoto

bet10ribu

situs toto

topslot88

topslot88

topslot88

sayangbet

topslot88

kakek111

slot

cancer toto

babeltoto

toto macau

licin4d

batak5d

bolaslot99

bolaslot99

mbahslot

tasiktoto

situs toto

situs toto

hukum toto

situs toto

situs toto

pucuk4d

pucuk4d

dvtoto

dvtoto

berlian789

toto

ทดลองเล่นสล็อต

DEWALANGIT

RAJA88

best crypto casinos online

https://wak89.org/

grafikjitu login

https://wakmariot89.com/

bydplay

bydplay

bydplay

rajalangit77

tasiktoto

sayangbet

babeltoto

babeltoto

babeltoto

best crypto casinos

wisdomtoto

Jakartaslot88

mama togel

Jakartaslot88

Jakartaslot88

Jakartaslot88

sayangbet

Jakartaslot88

babeltoto

wisdomtoto

tasiktoto

slot88 resmi

babeltoto

pucuk4d

pucuk4d

pucuk4d

bandar togel

kakaktogelvip.org

info bocoran rtp

bengkulutoto

mataramtoto

slot gacor

faster payout online casinos

watitoto

slot gacor

situs toto

cancertoto

https://dinporapar.purbalinggakab.go.id/

cancer toto

kaya 787

damaibet

babeltoto

babeltoto

RAJALANGIT77

situs toto

situs toto

babeltoto

kimia4d

kimia4d

kimia4d

wisdomtoto

berlian789

mataramtoto

bengkulutoto

yumetoto

medantoto

medantoto

medantoto

damaibet

situs toto

situs toto

hukumtoto

wisdomtoto

flokitoto

damaibet

situs toto

medantoto

medantoto

jogjatoto

inclave casinos login

mpo500 login

pucuk4d

slot thailand

pucuk4d

kari4d

mama togel

kari4d

babeltoto

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

pangkutoto login

slot gacor

gaya4d

gaya4d

sistem4d

sistem4d

winsortoto login

winsortoto login

winsortoto login

winsortoto login

winsortoto login

winsortoto login

mataramtoto

hukumtoto

hukumtoto

cancer toto

cancer toto

sayangbet

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

cancer toto

mpo500

paito sdy

paito sgp

paito hk

tasiktoto

tasiktoto

slot

papuatoto

slot 5k

babeltoto

kakaktogel

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

tegaltoto

desabet

desabet

tegaltoto