Does anyone out there actually use TiVo’s podcasting client? I saw it appear on both my boxes after a system update around six months ago or so and putzed around with it then; it felt raw and unpolished, so I figured I’d check in again a little bit later to see if the folks at TiVo had made any progress. I just tried the application out again, though, and have to say it’s just awful.

When you’re listening to a podcast, you can’t pause it, nor can you fast-forward or rewind within it; it seems like all these options would be available to you given that you’re listening on a freakin’ TiVo. If you want to walk away from a podcast, you have to just stop it, and then the only option available to you later is to restart it and listen from the beginning. What? Could this break the TiVo playback model any more? (Fascinatingly, a TiVo employee revealed how little they get it in a post to the TiVo Community forums, where he said that the fast-forward, rewind, and pause functions weren’t available because most podcast servers don’t support them. Do the television broadcast networks support these functions? Of course they don’t — TiVo invented the technology that allows users to layer them atop television, but is acting like the same model wouldn’t work with podcasting.)

It’s also difficult to listen to podcasts that aren’t in the list that TiVo provides — you have to enter the URL manually, using the directional arrows and select button to type out each character of the address. There’s no option to use one of the many podcast directories to find the one you want, nor does TiVo provide any handy shortcuts for commonly-entered strings within the URL-entry interface (things like “.com” and whatnot, strings that have shortcuts in the interface in which you enter your email address during Guided Setup). There’s also no function that actually allows you to download and store podcasts as they become available so that you can listen to at your leisure; instead, each time you listen you have to download the podcast anew.

The whole thing is clumsy, and the interface feels like it’s doing everything it can to dissuade you from actually using it. Honestly, I’d expect more from TiVo than this piece of crap.


Have you every tried Galleon or this solution (

I have to agree, TiVo’s podcast app is pretty lame!

• Posted by: Alex on Jun 12, 2006, 7:04 AM

Especially after reading TivoPony’s comment, I almost think they’re confusing podcasts with streaming audio like Live365. For about an hour every day I listen to podcasts in the car, and I can assure you there’s no high-speed internet connection available then…:)

And it would be a truly wonderful addition if they could integrate video podcasts, like they do with Rocketboom, but just link to an outside source. I’d love to watch Diggnation on my TV!

• Posted by: Ronald Bruintjes on Jun 23, 2006, 3:16 PM

Yes, it’s rather sad that my PC can handle full-screen streaming video via the Internet, yet my TiVo drops out every few minutes when playing low bit-rate podcasts.

Totally unacceptable. It’s a shame, too. I’d love to have *real* podcast functionality from my device.

• Posted by: Jerry on Jun 23, 2006, 4:37 PM

How about letting users grab video podcasts through RSS feeds. Now that would be a feature. The “Podcaster” component in Tivo seems more like a “yeah we’ve got that too” feature.

• Posted by: Chris on Jun 27, 2006, 1:24 PM
Please note that comments automatically close after 60 days; the comment spammers love to use the older, rarely-viewed pages to work their magic. If comments are closed and you want to let me know something, feel free to use the contact page!